Writers Critiquing Fiction Group Meeting at Fountainbridge Library, Edinburgh.

Roger is second from the left

As the world’s first UNESCO City of Literature, it’s no surprise that Edinburgh boasts a vibrant community of writers. Among them, Edinburgh u3a - part of a national movement to promote positive ageing - hosts several groups dedicated to writing in all its forms. One of the newest, Writers Critiquing Fiction, is focused on helping talented fiction writers refine and publish their work.  

The group was founded by Roger M., a former primary school teacher and teaching head with a background in Science. Over the years, he helped his pupils with everything from tying shoelaces to building rockets! After retiring, Roger pursued his passion for storytelling and has since had his fiction published in various outlets.  

Writers Critiquing Fiction meets every other Tuesday in Fountainbridge Library, with around a dozen members and room for more. Writers submit their stories to Roger, who curates a ‘script’ of three pieces to be shared and critiqued in each session, rotating amongst the group. 

During meetings, authors read their stories aloud, and members offer constructive feedback to help refine and enhance their work. Despite being a newly formed group, it has already fostered a dynamic and supportive environment where many compelling stories have been shared.   

Roger joined u3a after a persistent friend’s encouragement, following his move back to Edinburgh from Aberdeen. While in Aberdeen, he was an active member of Lemon Tree Writers, a well-established and nurturing group that motivated him to enter writing competitions. Inspired by this experience, he brought a similar ethos to Edinburgh, aiming to instill confidence in writers to share their work.  

“I want to encourage people to write more”, Roger explains. “And if a story has potential, to consider submitting it to competitions.”  

With the help of Group Coordinator Louise Grimm, setting up the group was straightforward. After submitting a simple form, they shared details on the Edinburgh u3a website and other forums, quickly attracting members.   

Roger believes that anyone can start a group. It requires patience, flexibility and organisation, but ultimately, the group’s success comes from its members. “There’s so much life experience around the table,” he says. “Everyone gets involved, and everyone has a voice.”  

Inspired by Roger’s journey? Consider becoming a group leader yourself here.

Page last updated on 11th June 2025